Best known for its small-batch, premium ice cream made entirely from scratch, Papi’s Creamery has built a loyal following around its inventive weekly flavor drops. Owned and operated by ice cream aficionado Diego Diaz, the Yorktown-based shop offers everything from creamy classics to bold blends featuring hazelnut coffee swirls and unexpected flavor pairings that feel anything but ordinary.
Operating on a limited-release model, Papi’s creates anticipation and excitement with every new menu. Each Thursday at 7 p.m., a fresh lineup of handcrafted flavors goes live. They are available in limited quantities and often sell out quickly. “Since we offer everything in limited quantities, once flavors are gone, they’re gone for a while,” Diaz says. “Customers order as soon as the drop goes live and then choose from select pickup times over the weekend. We announce everything through Instagram, and customers can subscribe to our text list for a direct link to the Hot Plate storefront, the online platform, when the new flavors launch.”
The concept grew organically. “I started in 2018 just reviewing ice cream on Instagram to push myself to try new flavors,” Diaz says. “That passion turned into experimenting at home. Eventually I became a lead ice cream maker for three years, where I fell in love with developing original flavors. When I realized I could build a small-batch, limited-release model that let me control production and sell directly to customers, Papi’s Creamery was born. It grew from Instagram sales into our own kitchen and storefront.”
Behind the scenes, production is a carefully timed, hands-on process beginning almost as soon as one drop ends. From Thursday through Friday, and sometimes into Monday, nearly everything is made in-house. That includes the ice cream base itself along with the brownies, cookies, fudge and swirls folded into each batch. By early in the week, the focus shifts to packing pints in preparation for the next Thursday night release. It is a steady rhythm of prep, pack and repeat, all building toward that 7 p.m. drop.
Creativity drives the menu. Diaz keeps a running list of flavor ideas and is constantly refining combinations. “I always start with a base flavor, such as strawberry, lemon or cookies and cream, and then I add a swirl and a crunch or something solid to give it texture,” he says. By rotating flavors weekly, the shop avoids repetition while keeping the experience fresh for returning customers. Certain flavors, however, have become consistent favorites. “Anything with coffee or Biscoff tends to be the first to go. Those are almost guaranteed sellouts,” he adds.
Outside of the creamery, Diaz is a new dad with an eight-month-old at home. Family time is a top priority, and he makes a conscious effort to be fully present with his wife and child. He also works as a coach and trainer at Coastal Strength & Fitness, balancing entrepreneurship, fitness and fatherhood with intention.
When asked what he hopes customers feel with their first bite, Diaz pauses. “I want them to take a bite and just have to stop for a second because it’s that good. That pause in life when something is so enjoyable you almost melt for a minute. And then, maybe the next time they try that flavor, they remember that moment and come back.”
At its heart, Papi’s Creamery is about more than just ice cream. It is about creativity, anticipation, and connection, turning a simple scoop into an experience people look forward to week after week.
TO THE POINT:
Papi’s Creamery
Address: 2900 Hampton Hwy., Yorktown, VA 23693
Contact: Diego Diaz, owner
Email: papiscreamery@gmail.com
Website: papiscreamery.com
